Is heroin a better methadone than methadone?

BACKGROUND: There is increasing evidence that health-related quality of life (HRQOL) is associated with a successful treatment and better outcome in opioid addiction. The aim of the present study was the longitudinal investigation of HRQOL in patients with severe opioid dependence, who were randomly assigned to four groups of medical and psychosocial treatment: heroin (diacetylmorphine) versus methadone and case management (CM) versus psychoeducation (PSE) respectively.

METHODS: HRQOL (MSQoL) and physical health (OTI) were investigated in 938 subjects, who participated in the German multi-centre study examining the effects of heroin-assisted treatment in patients with severe opioid dependence. Data for the present analysis were taken from baseline and 12-month follow up.

RESULTS: Under both forms of maintenance and psychosocial treatment HRQOL improved significantly during the observation period. HRQOL improvement under maintenance with heroin exceeded improvement under methadone, especially with regard to subjective physical health. HRQOL improvement was significantly associated with better expert-rated physical health. Further analyses showed significant better improvement of HRQOL in subjects treated with PSE compared with CM.

CONCLUSIONS: The advantage of heroin with regard to the improvement of HRQOL may be partially explained by a better improvement of physical health under maintenance with heroin compared with methadone, which highlights the importance of a comprehensive model of health care for patients with severe opioid dependence. Future studies need to investigate the benefits of PSE for patients in maintenance therapy.

Source: “Quality of life under maintenance treatment with heroin versus methadone in patients with opioid dependence.” from Drug and alcohol dependence. 2010 Aug 19

Martin Booth’s books Cannabis: A History and Opium: A History are both excellent. And Muscle is a very well written, first hand account of the world of bodybuilding and steroids. The World of Caffeine is a great book about just that.

Related Posts:

Do people who smoke marijuana have more sex partners?

What happens when nonsmokers wear nicotine patches?

Advice on how to best use caffeine — from a neuroscientist

You should follow me on Twitter here. You can also subscribe to the blog’s feed or follow on Facebook. Here are the site’s most popular posts of all time.