Skip to main content

Does electing a black mayor reduce the number of police officers killed in a city?

In a recent publication Kaminsky and Stucky (2009) claim our finding that the presence of a black mayor reduces killings of police officers (see Jacobs & Carmichael 2002) does not hold after they correct an error I made in the 2002 publication. Kaminsky and Stucky, however, ignore our most comprehensive models, which included a nonlinear specification with considerable explanatory power. They instead confine their reanalysis to a simplified and initial less exhaustive model in our paper that did not include the nonlinear specification without mentioning this and other omissions. After I correct my error, and retain the nonlinear specification that was in our definitive models, multiple versions of this model continue to support our hypothesis that the presence of a black mayor reduces killings of police officers. This comment concludes by outsome problems in Kaminski and Stucky’s analysis of later data.

Source: “The Influence of Black Mayors on Police Officers Killed: A Comment on Kaminski and Stucky” from Homicide Studies

Over 500,000 people have subscribed. Get my free newsletter every two weeks here.

Related posts:

What should you say to the police when you get pulled over for speeding?

Can you tell if someone is a Republican or Democrat just by looking at their face?

You just committed murder. What should you do now?

Get the newsletter

Free, every two weeks, plus the beginning of Plays Well With Others as a free PDF.

Close

Over 500,000 people have subscribed to my newsletter. Join free and get the beginning of Plays Well With Others:Over 500,000 people have subscribed. Get my free newsletter.

I want to subscribe!Subscribe